Why do the French besiege Paris?, by Valeria Verbinina for VZGLYAD. 01.29.2024.
It is not some foreign conquerors who intend to starve Paris, but French farmers. “We will blockade the city until Parisians experience first-hand what food shortages are like,” their representatives say. The blockade of Paris by agricultural tractors begins on Monday. Why did the French peasantry stage a real riot?
A sharp escalation of the confrontation between the French authorities and agricultural workers began a few weeks ago. One of the reasons is that since last year, new laws, regulations and recommendations on the distribution of subsidies for those involved in agriculture have come into force.
Unfortunately, no matter how beautiful France is, it remains largely a country of bureaucrats. As soon as they came into force, the new regulations began to acquire orders, additions and accumulate inevitable contradictions. To resolve them, new orders were invented, which first had to be agreed upon - and so on endlessly.
As Le Monde writes very vaguely , “agricultural workers are dissatisfied with the abundance of norms and regulations arising from them... many also complain about the complex procedure for accessing assistance from the authorities.” And while bureaucrats are issuing more and more pieces of paper, sweating from administrative zeal, farmers are left without money and without a clear understanding of when this disgrace will end.
Another reason for dissatisfaction is that the government, under pressure from the “greens,” is actively imposing measures on producers that are good in theory, but difficult to implement in practice. From a significant reduction in the use of pesticides and antibiotics to a mandatory requirement that, starting in 2024, some land should be left fallow, that is, unplanted for at least a year.
As Damien Brunel, head of the FGC trade union, noted , “It’s in vain that some people think that such land will turn into flowering fields... you still have to tinker with it, clear it of weeds and cultivate it.” That is, not only do people actually lose part of the land on which they could grow something, but they will also have to spend time and money, receiving absolutely nothing in return.
Agricultural producers also have other complaints - that the government does not sufficiently protect their products, in particular wines and cheeses, on international markets.
The fact that the authorities are consistently reducing subsidies for diesel fuel, which is extremely important for the functioning of the industry. And finally, the lack of response to the epidemic of epizootic hemorrhagic disease (EHD). Since autumn it has affected some cattle in France. Some animals died, farmers had to treat others at their own expense, the export market closed - and at the same time, problems with selling products within the country worsened.
As a matter of fact, it was precisely because of the epizootic - more precisely, because the authorities stubbornly did not want to notice its consequences - that the confrontation began, eventually taking on such a serious scale. Only when reports from literally everywhere in the province began to come in about spontaneous protests by farmers, including blocking roads with tractors, as well as burning tires and bales of hay near administrative buildings, the government decided to compromise.
On January 18, it promised that the state would reimburse 80% of payments for veterinary services and 80% of the cost of dead animals, and packages of documents for damages could be submitted “in early February.” But it wasted time - and besides, a concession on one point at this stage no longer meant much, because the other problems remained.
And more and more often another problem began to arise - the most important one, with which no one knows what to do. The point is that agricultural workers, in principle, earn too little.
The unrest shaking French society to some extent reflects the antagonism between the capital and the provinces. The farmers' protests mainly affected provincial cities - Bordeaux, Lyon, Rennes, Nantes and others, and one of the slogans of the spontaneous movement was “Do we have to die so that you are fed?” already makes this division between “we” and “you”. In this scheme, “we” are the workers who work tirelessly, who are also obliged to provide a thousand pieces of paper to the top and endlessly rewrite them if even one squiggle is put wrong, and “you” – who only consume without having any obligations.
At the same time, farmers cannot hide the fact that competitors abroad are not asleep. At least in Spain, where labor in the industry is two times cheaper (on average 7 euros per hour, not 15), and the fact that in some EU countries the requirements for agriculture are not as stringent and categorical as in France.
Now it looks like after the provinces, the French capital will have to bear the brunt of the ongoing confrontation.
Irritation in society has already reached the point that trade unionist Maxime Buizard proposed “blocking Paris and its little crown.” By the latter we mean a belt of suburbs that surround the capital in a dense ring. “The idea is that not a single truck will be able to enter the capital next week (that is, from January 29). If necessary, we will blockade the city until the Parisians experience first-hand what food shortages are like. But then they will understand that they need agriculture in order to live,” he said.
At first it seemed that this proposal was too bold to be attempted. However, at a meeting of agricultural unions on Saturday evening, an action plan was developed and a communiqué was published, which stated that “beginning at 2 pm on January 29, agricultural workers ... are undertaking an indefinite siege of the nation’s capital.”
The word “siege” used in the text (yes, that’s it) involuntarily recalls the times described either by Dumas or by Druon. It is, of course, interesting to read about them, but the question is what is it like to live in them, even if this is the 21st century and a “siege” is called the blocking of roads by tractors that lead to the capital. “We will close the strategic road arteries that lead to Paris,” promised the head of the JA union, Clément Torpier. – We are aware that traffic will be difficult... How long this will last depends on the government. If it is necessary to keep (the siege) for several days, it will last for several days.”
On Sunday, newly-minted Prime Minister Gabriel Attal hurriedly went on a visit to one of the farms in the province, where, in the style of Macron, he made many words and promised to encourage all that is good against all that is bad, but in a practical sense nothing concrete. Meanwhile, on the main news channel BFMtv, farmer Severin Sargent, who supports the blockade of Paris, has already promised Parisians a “black week.” “Tractors will advance towards the capital along all the main highways, either quickly and continuously, or in stages... Parisians need to understand that a black week awaits them,” he announced.
The Minister of the Interior, Gérald Darmanin, did not reflect on the extent to which these words were a bold bluff, the purpose of which was to extract further concessions, but gathered his subordinates and ordered all measures to be taken to maintain order and prevent a complete blockade of the capital region. In turn, farmers promise to go all the way. However, in any case, time will tell what exactly the next week will be like and what it will bring.
https://vz.ru/world/2024/1/29/1250737.html